Why Is Liberty Mutual So Expensive? (9 Reasons Why)

Although it could appear random, there are valid explanations for why your insurance pricing fluctuates.

Adding extra drivers to your policy, filing claims, your driving record, and even your credit score can all affect how much you pay for car insurance.

However, they may also alter by several factors beyond your control. That said, let’s find out why Liberty Mutual is so expensive!

Why Is Liberty Mutual So Expensive?

Liberty Mutual is so expensive due to several factors. These include your driving record and whether you were recently involved in a car accident. In addition, Liberty Mutual offers extensive coverage options, high-quality insurance, and a wide range of products that can all add up to how expensive their insurance is. Other reasons could be the type of vehicle you drive, discounts no longer available, and different policy fees.  

Learn more about why Liberty Mutual is so expensive. Here are nine reasons I’ve gathered in this post. Keep reading!

1. Your Driving Record

Accidents, even those in which you are not at fault, speeding tickets, reckless driving, and drunk driving all have the potential to raise premiums.

That said, you can see a rise in your premium if you’ve claimed it in the last several years. But, of course, you’ve done it before, but try to keep your guard and practice safe driving.

Limiting your losses will diminish the number of previous claims on your driving record.

2. Extensive Coverage Options

They charge a lot for their coverage options. It could be because they have higher deductibles than other companies or because they offer more coverage options than most competitors.

Read More:  Why Does My Car Horn Sound Weak? (9 Reasons Why)

For example, Liberty Mutual provides coverage for all types of cars—from small sedans to large SUVs—and they often have higher deductibles than other insurers.

3. Offers High-Quality Insurance

They charge higher rates than their competitors do despite offering lower deductibles and similar amounts of coverage options.

Therefore, they can charge higher rates than other companies because they’re willing to take on more risk by charging special premiums.

But they are still offering high-quality insurance protection at an affordable price (or vice versa).

Also, the company is trying to make money off customers who don’t need as much coverage as others (e.g., older drivers).

4. Offers A Wide Range Of Products

Liberty Mutual is a premium auto insurance provider. The company offers a wide range of products.

But unlike most other insurers, it charges an annual premium separate from your vehicle’s cost.

Therefore, it means you’re paying for Liberty Mutual’s entire product line up-front, whether or not you need any part of it.

So if you’re looking for an affordable way to protect your car, Liberty Mutual might be your last option.

5. Depending On The Car You Drive

Depending On The Car You Drive

A new car typically costs more to fix following a significant accident. New cars are more vulnerable to theft or break-ins.

With that, talk to your provider about how your premiums will change if you purchase the ideal car you’ve always desired.

Also, don’t forget that other types of vehicles are also highly susceptible to theft. For example, thieves also prey on cars with expensive parts.

6. Expensive Policy Fees

Their policy fees. While all insurance companies charge different rates for policies, Liberty Mutual’s policy fees tend to be higher than other providers’ fees.

Read More:  Why Is My Coolant Orange? (7 Reasons Why)

It is because Liberty Mutual uses a risk-based pricing model rather than a fee-for-service model, which means that they charge more money to cover your risk if you have a higher risk of incurring an accident or illness.

As a result, their overhead costs are higher than those of other insurers, meaning they must pay higher premiums on average.

7. Putting Additional Driver To Your Policy

All the above elements may affect your rate as they relate to an additional driver on your insurance.

As you might expect, the high risk of new drivers can typically increase your rate when you add a young driver.

So, if you’re anxious about getting insurance for your teen driver, they can be eligible for the Good Student Discount if they have a grade point average of at least a B.

To see how much you may save, start your auto insurance quote with Liberty Mutual.

8. Discounts Changed

When you purchase your first policy with a car insurance company, like Liberty Mutual, they might give you an initial discount.

Or perhaps they began charging a charge to continue getting paper bills.

If you have any questions, verify your statement and contact your provider. That’s why comparing insurance providers are crucial to ensure you’re receiving the most excellent deal.

For example, many different vehicle insurance savings are available from Liberty Mutual, ranging from going paperless to purchasing a new policy when your current one expires.

In addition, you can tailor your insurance so that you only spend on what you require in addition to discounts.

Read More:  Why Do Head Gaskets Blow? (11 Reasons Why)

9. Mutual Company

They are the most expensive car insurance company in the U.S., and that’s because they’ve been around for over 100 years.

In addition, they’re a mutual company, so they don’t have shareholders to pay dividends to or stockholders to answer to.

So instead, they rely on the investment of their policyholders—and those investment dollars help them stay in business when life throws them curveballs like natural disasters (like hurricanes and floods) or unforeseen events (like terrorism).

To know more, you can also read our posts on why Porsches are so expensive, why your car interest rate is so high, and why Nissan Altima insurance is so high


From what this post has gathered about Liberty Mutual, you may now understand different reasons and factors why Liberty Mutual is so expensive.

And if you’re looking for cheap insurance, Liberty Mutual might not be the best choice. However, remember that even if Liberty Mutual is expensive, they offer one of the best policies among insurance providers.

Leave a Comment